Go back

"The Real Reason We Lost" - JD Vance

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
They are related.

The Administration might have known the war was unpopular, but they didn't realize how badly it would cost them in this election. They thought they could mitigate the losses with culture war issues and personal attacks.

But a loss of something like 50 seats in the House and the stunning Senate defeats are a wakeup call to even people as stubborn an ...[text shortened]... of touch as this Administration is composed of.

We'll see but I have a strong feeling I'm right.
Remember this?

I don't care about the midterms': Trump makes clear he's in no rush to reach deal with Iran

https://abcnews.com/Politics/care-midterms-trump-makes-clear-rush-reach-deal/story?id=133357778

Trump needs democrats to end the war so he can save face. He will never get a better deal than the one Obama brokered that he broke. And since Ted Cruz wanted to break that deal just like Trump did it would ruin his chances of becoming POTUS.

Either that or a ground war to attempt regime change is imminent.
Personally, I don't think Trump wants a deal that Iran will agree to. He just wants to continue the blockade hoping to wear them down before the whole world is worn down by high oil prices. He thinks time is on his side.


@Metal-Brain said
Remember this?

I don't care about the midterms': Trump makes clear he's in no rush to reach deal with Iran

https://abcnews.com/Politics/care-midterms-trump-makes-clear-rush-reach-deal/story?id=133357778

Trump needs democrats to end the war so he can save face. He will never get a better deal than the one Obama brokered that he broke. And since Ted Cruz wanted to ...[text shortened]... ear them down before the whole world is worn down by high oil prices. He thinks time is on his side.
Trump says a lot of things almost all of them untrue.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
Trump says a lot of things almost all of them untrue.
I agree.

But isn't it convenient that this is part of a larger pattern of midterm elections going to the opposite party of the executive branch? How better to fool people into thinking that is why there is little change? But you can see how in certain times certain congress people like Kyrsten Sinema defected to the other side when needed to maintain the status quo when it was preferred by the Rockefeller and JP Morgan descendants.

Who was the other turncoat that defected when the descendants of the robber baron elites wanted them to? It was a man. What was that traitor's name? They both defected when there was not enough gridlock to do it in a purely partisan way. You are a partisan, yet smart fellow. I'll bet you know. Who is that dirt bag?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said

Seriously though, should a nation continue a war that the People oppose in a democratic republic?
Trump is in serious breach of the Constitution by continuing this war beyond the time limit allowed in the emergency powers act (or whatever it is called). No, ceasefires do not stop the clock, and even if Trump counts the days when no shot was fired, his foreign escapade is still way past the time limit. Congress should grow some balls and terminate funding for this war. I hope the new Democratically-dominated Congress puts a stop to this folly promptly and holds him to account for unnecessary deaths, of American service members, America's allies in the ME, and Iranians.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Very-Rusty said
As we have learned on this Site over the years. Personal attacks don't get us anywhere. Personally I've proven this many times over the years but have mellowed out. I actually listen to what the other person has to say now and think about it.

I believe everyone saw what was going to happen in the Mid-Term elections, just no one predicted it would be as big a win as it t ...[text shortened]... wonder how many will be fired over this? Looks like the Minister of War is on his way out!!!

-VR
I think we will soon see some resignations or 're-assignments' from within Trump's inner circle.

1 edit

@moonbus said
Trump is in serious breach of the Constitution by continuing this war beyond the time limit allowed in the emergency powers act (or whatever it is called). No, ceasefires do not stop the clock, and even if Trump counts the days when no shot was fired, his foreign escapade is still way past the time limit. Congress should grow some balls and terminate funding for this war. I h ...[text shortened]... ount for unnecessary deaths, of American service members, America's allies in the ME, and Iranians.
My guess is the war will be over before the new Congress gets seated. Articles like this are all over the web today:

https://www.wral.com/news/ap/53ed5-iran-is-reviewing-proposals-focusing-on-tehran-s-nuclear-program-officials-say/

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/trump-planning-double-deal-with-putin-to-end-two-wars/ar-AA2gSHYX?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=6aee51ac9aa5490c8b1fc77a6549deca&ei=18&cvpid=6aee51c054904d18a92f8b389e1dd410

The first order of business is likely to be a rollback of his tariffs; it'll be interesting to see how many Republicans are willing to risk their political futures by voting against it. I think it's quite likely they'll be able to muster veto proof majorities in support of ending most of Trump's tariffs.

Then we'll see what the budget negotiations look like.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
I think we will soon see some resignations or 're-assignments' from within Trump's inner circle.
It sure needs some shake ups for sure!!!

Perhaps things will get back to normal after the present President is gone.

Lost control of both houses which the Dems now control. Well as of Jan 2027

-VR

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Very-Rusty said
It sure needs some shake ups for sure!!!

Perhaps things will get back to normal after the present President is gone.

Lost control of both houses which the Dems now control. Well as of Jan 2027

-VR
There will be no going back to way the things were before Trump. There will be some other 'new normal', but it won't ever return to what it was before Trump. The world has had a 'wake up' call and is isolating America; that will have repercussions for generations to come. It should not even have been possible for one man to set the world's economies in such turmoil, and the rest of the world is already insulating itself from America because of Trump. Look at how Canada has responded, for example, setting up its own trade agreement with the EU.

Xi was right when he observed that America is a nation in decline--Trump was wrong to think he is the one reversing the decline. I can even imagine the Bretton Woods agreement being abandoned and the dollar rejected as the world's reference currency.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
My guess is the war will be over before the new Congress gets seated. Articles like this are all over the web today:

https://www.wral.com/news/ap/53ed5-iran-is-reviewing-proposals-focusing-on-tehran-s-nuclear-program-officials-say/

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/trump-planning-double-deal-with-putin-to-end-two-wars/ar-AA2gSHYX?ocid=hpmsn&cvid=6aee51ac9aa5490c ...[text shortened]... support of ending most of Trump's tariffs.

Then we'll see what the budget negotiations look like.
Iran certainly has a stronger diplomatic position now, and America has a weaker military position (having lost several key support bases in the ME). Whether he ever admits it or not, Trump lost this war; Trump's going to eat crow.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
My guess is the war will be over before the new Congress gets seated.
I suppose it all depends on whether the Iranians value money more than life and limb and whether they will take American agreements seriously again. Let's not forget, they did have an agreement in place.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
There will be no going back to way the things were before Trump. There will be some other 'new normal', but it won't ever return to what it was before Trump. The world has had a 'wake up' call and is isolating America; that will have repercussions for generations to come. It should not even have been possible for one man to set the world's economies in such turmoil, an ...[text shortened]... e Bretton Woods agreement being abandoned and the dollar rejected as the world's reference currency.
As a Canadian, I would say Trump brought it upon himself. His tarrif's were competely ridiculous and hurt his own people. I don't know he even cares about his own people. Just lining his pockets and the pockets of his rich friends. He had people in positions they knew nothing about. I think you will see some of them be impeached. I don't understand how he got voted in the second time after what happened in his first term as POTUS.

I agree things will never get back the way they were with the trade, but the people of Canada have no problems with Americans, just ONE TRUMP!!! You will see more people visiting the U.S. once he is gone. I don't know if he understood how much we actually need each other.

-VR

Vote Up
Vote Down

@kmax87 said
I suppose it all depends on whether the Iranians value money more than life and limb and whether they will take American agreements seriously again. Let's not forget, they did have an agreement in place.
You think that being blockaded and subject to attacks by the US military on a regular basis is a desirable situation for the Iranians? They'll endure it if they have to but I wouldn't underestimate the pain it is causing their People. Even mullahs can't ignore that forever.

1 edit

@no1marauder said
You think that being blockaded and subject to attacks by the US military on a regular basis is a desirable situation for the Iranians? They'll endure it if they have to but I wouldn't underestimate the pain it is causing their People. Even mullahs can't ignore that forever.
They may prefer pain to capitulation. How proud are they? Their culture predates Islam and their greatest figure is Cyrus, who ironically the evangelists and christian nationalists have projected on to Trump as being their saviour from Godless liberalism. But I digress.

All I am saying is the Iranian mindset is not captive to 4 year American political cycles. They are not as easily distracted as we are. What if they see this moment as the perfect moment to really give America a blood nose? Stubbornness can be a very powerful motivation.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@kmax87 said
They may prefer pain to capitulation. How proud are they? Their culture predates Islam and their greatest figure is Cyrus, who ironically the evangelists and christian nationalists have projected on to Trump as being their saviour from Godless liberalism. But I digress.

All I am saying is the Iranian mindset is not captive to 4 year American political cycles. They are not a ...[text shortened]... perfect moment to really give America a blood nose? Stubbornness can be a very powerful motivation.
An end to the blockade and sanctions plus inspections they've already agreed to once = "capitulation"?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
An end to the blockade and sanctions plus inspections they've already agreed to once = "capitulation"?
Do we have any sense as to how unanimous their acceptance of the agreement was? Is it just America breaking ceasefires? Are there factions that are diametrically opposed to agreement that are not being included in negotiations because the Americans under this administration are very incompetent in their assessment of the problem?