@my2sons saidYou and the other right wingers are the ones obsessed with such minutiae.
@no1marauder
You obviously do not have daughters or probably don't have any women in your life. If so, would you like some dude hanging out his junk before young girls in a bathroom or locker room. If so, you are a deviant pervert.
1 edit
@Mott-The-Hoople saidYour link kinda proves my point:
plenty of evidence out their...my main evidence is my own eyes, ears and the ability to have common sense.
https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/trans-women-retain-athletic-edge-after-year-hormone-therapy-study-n1252764
I see you didnt address womens right to privacy...thats because cant.
" Prior to starting hormones, they performed fewer pushups and had slower running times than the cisgender men in the control group. A year into treatment, though, those differences disappeared."
And again these are comparisons between the "average" transgender women v. the "average" cisgender one not between a transgender woman and a woman athlete.
I think if you had bothered to read the article, you'd know it gave very little support to your claim.
" A transgender woman who transitions before or at puberty, “doesn't really have any advantage” when it comes to athletic performance, he said. “So that young lady should be allowed to compete with all the other people who are born women.”
OOPS!
@no1marauder said"" A transgender woman who transitions before or at puberty, “doesn't really have any advantage” when it comes to athletic performance, he said. “So that young lady should be allowed to compete with all the other people who are born women.”'
Your link kinda proves my point:
" Prior to starting hormones, they performed fewer pushups and had slower running times than the cisgender men in the control group. A year into treatment, though, those differences disappeared."
And again these are comparisons between the "average" transgender women v. the "average" cisgender one not between a transgender wom ...[text shortened]... young lady should be allowed to compete with all the other people who are born women.[/b]”
OOPS!
So you are agreeing that all transgender that transitioned AFTER puberty has an unfair advantage. finally!
@Mott-The-Hoople saidDoes your article say that?
"" A transgender woman who transitions before or at puberty, “doesn't really have any advantage” when it comes to athletic performance, he said. “So that young lady should be allowed to compete with all the other people who are born women.”'
So you are agreeing that all transgender that transitioned AFTER puberty has an unfair advantage. finally!
UMM, no.
@Mott-The-Hoople saidYou should know, being as mental as is possible for a supposed human to be.
the words you should be studying are "mental issues"
@Mott-The-Hoople saidAGAIN....
men without dicks...is that better? Its impossible to change your sex
the numbers are much higher than what you suggest as shown in link I will post.
how many compete that havent publicly announced
https://www.outsports.com/2024/12/6/22948400/transgender-trans-athlete-championship-national-world-title/
Define gender.
Go ahead, but I'm not waiting for your answer.
Because you clearly have no idea what it is.
@AverageJoe1 saidYes, it IS.
thatis not the issueis it.
Just a reminder. We do not need to listen to your proof that you're an idiot.
We're well aware, unlike you about gender.
@AverageJoe1 saidI'm trying to educate you.
Seriously, this post has no meaning. It says nothing. I simply asked if a biological male sholuld be allowed to compete against a biological female. Further I wanted him to tell me what HE thinks, not what a link thinks. Not too much to ask. All children born, except for the abnormal, have ON THEIR BIRTH CERTIFICATE whether they are male or female. Maruader keeps ...[text shortened]... te to the competition.
Sue, why could you not answer the question like that and get some creds?
This is what makes your posts so purely unreadable.
The sheer ignorance.
DEFINE GENDER.
Look it up if you have to. Damn.
@AverageJoe1 saidThe answer is purely about gender.
I understand the distinction you’re making between biological sex and gender, but you’re changing the subject. As usual. The question isn’t whether gender has an important sociological role. It’s whether biological sex is relevant when determining eligibility for women’s sports. Geez. You kids.
Gender may be the adjective, as you put it. But in women’s sports, the no ...[text shortened]... y to make your groundless arguments.
How to tighten it up a little bit.
Don’t be a wild house
Get a neon sign to put over your head.
"No, I'm not WITH stupid, I AM stupid."
@Metal-Brain saidYou often wonder that?
I looked up penis transplant and got nothing. I don't think it is possible to give a female a penis. So I often wounder what the point is of a woman transitioning to a man if she cannot get a penis.
@Suzianne saidYeah it is absolutely despicable with these THOUSANDS of trans 'ladies' forcing their way into women's sports and winning title after title after title where there are almost no vagina's in sight........ Yep, we need to fight this INVASION.....
Yes, it IS.
Just a reminder. We do not need to listen to your proof that you're an idiot.
We're well aware, unlike you about gender.
@Suzianne saidWhy do liberals keep saying to define gender???? to what? We might be discussing whether a man should be allowed to compete with the woman, and they write back, telling us to define gender.
AGAIN....
Define gender.
Go ahead, but I'm not waiting for your answer.
Because you clearly have no idea what it is.
Really queer stuff. Please put me on record as not knowing how to define gender. And then y’all have at it.
@AverageJoe1 saidWhat you are after is a severe reduction of freedoms besides control of our bodies and if some dude wants a whack job on his penis or whatever they do, that is HIS FKING decision and NONE of yours and your specious argument about women's sports is just a red herring. Hey, I like my own penis just like it is so don't go down any of the available gay insults. It is NONE of your fking business what people do with their bodies, and that includes women's right to abortion.
Why do liberals keep saying to define gender???? to what? We might be discussing whether a man should be allowed to compete with the woman, and they write back, telling us to define gender.
Really queer stuff. Please put me on record as not knowing how to define gender. And then y’all have at it.
Hey, give me a list of how many sports titles were won by trans men, now women.
@sonhouse saidI agree, a man can do what he wants to with his person. BUT, Did you know that your people want me, avJoe , to pay for it? They wrote me just yesterday that I should pay for such operations. Did you get such a letter? Are you going to fight it?
What you are after is a severe reduction of freedoms besides control of our bodies and if some dude wants a whack job on his penis or whatever they do, that is HIS FKING decision and NONE of yours and your specious argument about women's sports is just a red herring. Hey, I like my own penis just like it is so don't go down any of the available gay insults. It is NONE of you ...[text shortened]... right to abortion.
Hey, give me a list of how many sports titles were won by trans men, now women.